The market volatility which was missing back in the last quarter of 2010 into the first few months of 2011 came to visit in March as an unexpected earthquake and devastating tsunami in Japan, along with continued tensions and unrest in the Middle East sent global markets lower. In just two and one half weeks, the S&P 500 lost 7%, while global markets declined even more. In the subsequent two weeks the markets surprisingly recovered fueled by in-line or better than expected economic data. The Federal Reserve continued its quantitative easing program increasing liquidity into the system; which has been finding its way into commodities; as the price of oil and soft commodities continued to rise during the quarter.
Amidst the natural disasters and geopolitical unrest, the S&P 500 ended the first quarter up 5.4%, excluding dividends. Within the market, small caps outperformed large caps and the US Energy sector led with an impressive 16.8% rise amid political tensions in the Middle East. Energy stocks have now gained almost 40% in the past year. Developed markets outperformed emerging markets and Europe finished up 4.5%. Fixed Income underperformed equities due to fears of inflation and rising interest rates. Treasuries were basically flat, while high yield, (+3.9%), preferreds, (+3.6%), and TIPS , (+2.1%), did the best.
The Federal Reserve Board continues a very aggressive monetary policy. At some point in 2011 this will likely change and recently there has been a growing minority of those on the board that QE2 should be halted on schedule at the end of June of this year. With the exception of Thomas Hoenig, no calls for an actual interest rate hike have been made. If the Federal Reserve does end QE2 on schedule (which it indicated it plans to do), it is possible the end to this policy could bring increased volatility to the markets as investors try to understand the implications to the economy moving forward; given the Fed has provided ongoing liquidity and support to the monetary system for well over 2 years and to the tune of almost $2 trillion.
Our current assessment is that the US stock market averages (based on S&P 500 index) are priced close to fair valuation given current earnings estimates and the possibility of future interest rate hikes, which lowers the amount investors are willing to pay for future corporate earnings. Earnings estimates have remained steady over the past several weeks, despite the earthquake in Japan and issues in the Middle East. As of April 1, 2011, earnings estimates were $97.00 for the full year ending December 2011, a 15.8% increase over final 2010 earnings of $83.77. Applying a price-earnings ratio of 13 and 14 to expected earnings for 2011 translates into a value of 1261 (based on 13) and 1358 (based on 14) for the S&P 500. The S&P 500 ended the first quarter at 1326, right in the range of fairly valued. If expectations for higher interest rates don’t materialize, it is possible the markets could trade higher (higher price-earnings ratio) as investors will be willing to pay more for future corporate earnings.

