Here is an interesting article by Steven Russolillo from the Wall Street Journal. It focuses on the January effect and some of the correlations between the first month of the new year vs. what we might expect for the rest of 2012.
The Dow Jones Industrial Average surged 415.35 points, or 3.4%, last month. It was the biggest January point gain in the Dow’s history and best percentage surge since 1997. The numbers look even better for the S&P 500 and Nasdaq
Composite. The S&P 500 jumped 4.4% last month, its biggest gain since 1997. And the tech-heavy Nasdaq advanced 8%, registering its best performance since 2001.
A majority of the January gains were accomplished in the first three weeks of the month, as stocks have leveled off during the past week. Skeptics say there’s not much justification for following the “January effect.” Just because the market moves a certain way in the first month of a calendar year shouldn’t necessary translate into future direction over the next 11 months. But for whatever reason, it’s hard to deny the pattern. The blue-chip Dow has matched the direction of the January performance in 85 of 114 years of the Dow’s history, according to WSJ Market Data Group, good for a 75% success rate. On top of that, when the Dow finished January with a gain, it ended the full year higher 82% of the time, according to WSJ data. When the Dow has risen in January during the years dating back to 1970, the rest of the year has followed suit 92% of the time.
Now that we’ve laid out all the bullish arguments, there are several caveats to consider. History isn’t always an accurate assessment of future performance. And this theory fails to take into account current market fundamentals. While 2012 has started strong, the rally has also shown signs of vulnerability. The Dow’s four-day losing streak is the longest skid since the end of November. About 1/3 of the price-weighted Dow’s monthly gain was concentrated in only one stock: Caterpillar. And Bank of America swiftly shifted from the Dow’s worst performer in 2011 to its top gainer last month, jumping 28%. Corporate earnings continue to be lackluster and Europe’s sovereign-debt crisis has the potential of flaring up at any given moment.
There are lots for investors to chew over in the coming days. And its worth noting that February is typically one of the worst months of the year for stocks. Investors will have to fight the seasonal tide if they want to push the market even higher. Since this post was heavily focused on the “January effect,” we’ll leave you with one final seasonal trend.
The Stock Trader’s Alamanc’s early 2012 indicators are a perfect three-for-three. The Santa Claus rally came to fruition. The “first five day” theory — which states the S&P 500 has never fallen in a year when the first five days see gains of 1.8% or more — was intact (the S&P 500 rose 1.8% in 2012′s first five trading days). And now the January barometer suggests future gains for the broad market. “Since 1950 this trifecta has occurred 27 times in 62 years,” according to the Almanac. “Full-year gains followed in 24 of the 26 previous occurrences, 92.3% of the time.”